CPNE finally had the decency to give investors a look at how Q2 numbers are going to come in, and a look at just how much damage the fraudulent credit cards actually hurt the company’s numbers.
CPNE has been in a free fall since making its new all time high at the end of February, and the value of the stock has been pretty much decimated. Investors have known for some time about the challenges they have had with chargebacks in Q1, but the company has refused to quantify the damage until this morning.
Personally, I feel the company’s “head in the sand” mentality is atrocious- For months now the market has been pricing in a “worst case” scenario. Finally, when the stock has been beaten down to a small fraction of its value just a few months ago, the management lets the public know the extend of the damage. In short- simply horrendous communication.
Public companies routinely issue earnings “guidance” well in advance of final earnings releases. Here’s the way I see it- CPNE should have issued guidance a long time ago and let investors decide for themselves if they wanted to hang in there. In the absence of information, you had to take your cues on the financial health of the company from the way the stock was behaving. If you looked at the chart, you had to assume the company was near bankruptcy.
Today, just prior to the open, CPNE issued a press release stating they would deliver about $11 million in revs and $2 million in operating income. Take out $500k for taxes, and whatever non cash charges are out there, and you have probably about $1 to $1.5 million in profits- or EPS in the $.02 to $.03 range.
The top line compares favorably with Q2 of 2006- They did about $7 million in the same quarter one year ago. However, the bottom line is taking a hit- last year they made $1.4 million on the $7 million in sales- margins have dropped from 22% to about 13% depending on where the final figures come in.
So, now we have a reasonable estimate on the hard numbers- and you can decide for yourself if you want to continue being a shareholder or become one. Personally, while I was impressed with what these guys have achieved in the past, I am extremely disappointed in their shareholder communications.
Something changed with this management team as we rolled into 2007. In the latter half of 2006 the company provided a constant stream of updates concerning their financial health and subscriber base. There were monthly subscriber number updates, and the stock traded very well. In 2007 they have chosen to remain mute about everything but new expansion programs. Some investors take these new initiatives as a sign they have already passed the steepest part of their growth curve.
Let’s look at the stock:
At today’s price of $.90, the stock market is saying the company is worth $45 million. Based on Q2 numbers, they should be delivering about $50 million in annual revenues, and earnings of around $5 million, or $.10 per share.
If margins do in fact come back in Q3, you would be looking at more like $.30 to $.40 EPS. Then, we would go back to the absurdly undervalued argument.
Clearly, CPNE has experienced a bump in the road. Whether or not it derails the company completely has yet to be determined.
I have no issue with the corporate performance- all companies suffer set backs. Some recover and go on to prosper- some don’t.
However, I do have an issue with the way they have handled their shareholder communications through the downturn. If you know what’s going on, you can make an informed decision about how to handle it. If you don’t you can lose money unnecessarily.
Here’s the bottom line- I will be looking to get out of this one if and when the stock improves. I can’t say the worst is behind, but the stock has lost 75% of its value since the end of February. It doesn’t seem like the company is worth 75% less, but that’s the way the market is valuing it for now.
The market has priced in a worst case scenario, and it’s not all that bad. However, I like being a shareholder of a company that lets you know what’s going on. I know I could end up selling at the bottom, but how would I ever know what’s going on so I could make an informed decision? I’ll be looking to get out on surges.
Comments and questions are welcome.