Home Page : www.otcjournal.com
Email Questions or Comments To:
editor@otcjournal.com
To
OTC Journal Members:
|
October. This is one of the
peculiarly dangerous months to speculate in stocks. The others are July,
January, September, April, November, May, March, June, December, August
and February.
-Mark Twain, Pudd'nhead Wilson |
 |
I Don't Trust
September |
|
I could have said I do trust September-
I trust September to be the worst month of the year. Since October, November,
December, and January are generally the best months of the year, September
is the best month to accumulate equities ahead of pending gains during
coming months.
Well known technical analyst Phil
Erlanger recently showed the second half of September is one of the worst
times of the year for the stock market. On the left is Phil's seasonality
study for a typical September:
Note the accelerating losses in September
as you get closer to the later trading days in the month. Hence, if history
repeats itself on years that end in 4, I would expect next week to be pretty
ugly. It will also represent an excellent opportunity to accumulate your
favorite equities before we roll into the the seasonally strongest time
of the year.
Erlanger focuses this study on years
that end in four. This relates to theories concerning market cycles with
a decade. The most prevalent theory suggests the market moves in four year
cycles. Within every decade, there are usually lows at the 2s and 6s, and
highs at 4's and 00's. More on this phenomenon in a future edition.
September has been reasonably friendly
so far, but don't trust it to remain so. Perhaps this year's tepid September
rebound (NASDAQ up about 40 points) is the result of the drubbing we took
from May through July.
On average, the S&P 500 drops
about 4% in September, and most of the damage usually occurs after options
expire (last Friday).
Yale Hirsch, one of the early pioneers
in technical analysis, did some interesting studies on this peculiar phenomenon.
Here's a table, measuring the percentage performance of the DOW taken from
October to April, and April to October over the last decade of the 20th
Century:
|
Year
|
Oct/April % Gain
|
April/October % Gain
|
|
1990
|
+18
|
-8
|
|
1991
|
+9
|
-6
|
|
1992
|
+3
|
-4
|
|
1993
|
0
|
+10
|
|
1994
|
+10.5
|
+6
|
|
1995
|
+15
|
+10
|
|
1996
|
+16
|
+8
|
|
1997
|
+21
|
+6
|
|
1998
|
+25
|
-5
|
|
1999
|
0
|
-.5
|
|
2000
|
-2
|
+2.2
|
|
Average % Gain
|
+9.05
|
+1.1
|
Based on these results investors
who bought stocks in October and sold in April made nine times the return
of investors who bought in April and sold in October. Yale Hirsch comments:
"October was the Bear Killer. Every major postwar bear market ended here
except 1970."
This table, contributed by Jason
Goepfert of SentimenTrader, breaks down the September/October relationship
more succinctly. Note the average return in the S&P 500 from September
to October has been about 1% since 1950.
An interesting point that jumps off
the page: If Sept is an up month there is a 57% chance October will also
be an up month. If September is a down month, there is a 63% chance October
will be an up month. Either way, we have a pretty good seasonal shot at
a strong October.
 |
Potential
Reasons For September Declines and October Surges |
 |
I believe the seasonality of business
plays a big role in this predictable cycle. Corporations tend to report
dismal performance this time of year. During the summer months business
slows considerably. In Europe, the month of August is almost canceled due
to lack of interest. People use the summer months to vacation and spend
time with their families as the kids are out of school.
Conversely, the 4th quarter tends
to be one of the busiest times of the year. Companies who have set annual
goals are pushing for business in the last quarter. Many US Government
contracts are awarded in the 4th quarter as agencies begin to spend the
budgets for the fiscal year. The Holiday Buying Season kicks in, which
is huge for the economy since the consumer represents nearly 70% of GDP.
In order to accommodate a healthy
Holiday Season, the FED generally pumps liquidity into the system, which
helps foster spending. The money flows around, and everyone prospers.
I also believe there is one more,
slightly insidious reason for the market's typical 4th qtr surge. Wall
Street is a giant marketing machine. This marketing machine knows everyone
tends to evaluate their investments towards the end of the year with an
eye towards what they will do next year. Wall Street wants you to feel
good about being in the market when you do your year end planning.
What better way to insure a strong
fourth quarter than to have the market tank in September.
 |
Conclusion |
 |
Over the past 25 years, investors
who bought stocks in October and sold in April made nine times the return
of investors who bought in April and sold in October.
As today is Yom Kippur, the day of
atonement in the Jewish Religion, perhaps it would be wise for me to reflect
on past market sins and try not to repeat those mistakes.
We are now coming out of the slowest
six month market environment in ten years. This year I stubbornly held
on to positions throughout the tepid summer months. I picked up one position
at $18 in February. After appreciating to $22, I watched the stock grind
its way down to $12 over the difficult May/June time frame. I wasn't smart
enough to sell it before it cratered, and I wasn't brave enough to pick
up more at $12. With the market slightly more favorable, the stock has
now rebounded to $15.
I will be tempted sell the position
if and when it climbs back to my cost basis. I am going to try to resist
the temptation. Rather, I will try to discipline myself to hold if it appreciates
beyond my cost basis and try to make the return I originally envisioned.
In fact, if the stock craters next
week in a tough market environment, I might even summon my courage and
add to the position.
In the interim, I have decided to
try to capitalize on the usually rough September by purchasing puts on
the market. A put is an option you buy when you want to bet equities will
go down.
This past week I picked up 60 Oct
35 puts on the QQQ's. They trade under the symbol QQQ.VI. I paid
$.70, for a total investment of about $4,200. I will be looking to close
out the position within the next two weeks even if it doesn't pay off.
If the market doesn't drop, I should be making up the difference from appreciation
in my portfolio on the stocks I am long.
This year I am going to sell a lot
of stocks if they appreciate seasonally. The rebound has begun. In our
universe of eight microcap stocks, six have appreciated off summer lows.
NWKI,
NWAV, NTDL, FMLY, HYPD, and VTSI have all rebounded in the last
thirty days. A hiccup next week should be a great buying opportunity. Pick
your favorite, and accumulate.
By the Spring I hope to have liquidated
enough stock to be about 25% invested. I'll never be completely out. I
love it too much.
Your comments and feedback are welcome.
Send me any question on any issue on your mind. You will get a candid answer.
Email editor@otcjournal.com.
Charts Provided Courtesy
Of TradePortal.com |