November 3, 2002
The Insiders' Indie
By JOSH ROTTENBERG
Joe Carnahan, a 32-year-old
screenwriter and director, has a joke he likes to tell about the way opinions
are formed in Hollywood. He first heard it from the actor Ray Liotta, and
over the past couple of years, in numerous retellings, it has attained
such significance to him, such potent explanatory power about how the business
works, that he has come to refer to it simply as the Joke. The joke goes
like this: Two agents -- or movie producers or studio executives -- are
walking down the hall, talking business. One turns to the other and asks,
''So what did you think of that screenplay that came in the other day?''
''I don't know,'' the
other one says with a shrug. ''I'm the only one who read it.''
On Dec. 20, in the heart
of what is traditionally Hollywood's prestige-film season, a low-budget
police drama called ''Narc,'' written and directed by Carnahan, will open
in selected cities and soon thereafter roll out across the country. Set
in the most blighted areas of Detroit in the bleak, gray midwinter, ''Narc''
tells the story of two burned-out cops, played by Liotta and Jason Patric,
trying to solve the brutal slaying of an undercover narcotics officer.
It's a tense and downbeat affair, punctuated by sudden eruptions of violence:
a man is stabbed in the neck with a needle, another is shot in the head
and a pregnant woman is struck in the belly by a stray bullet, killing
her unborn baby, all before the opening credits roll. Nearly every line
of dialogue is either shouted or spoken through clenched teeth, and every
punch, and there are many, sounds like a baseball bat hitting a brisket.
Given its grim subject
matter, $5 million budget and sub-A-list stars, ''Narc'' is the sort of
movie that, artistic merit notwithstanding, would often fail to secure
a theatrical release and wind up dumped onto the video store shelf, where
its heartbroken director will see a single forlorn copy sitting beside
16 of the Sylvester Stallone car-racing movie. Instead, ''Narc'' is being
unfurled with a full promotional press by a major studio, Paramount, on
Hollywood's all-important Christmas weekend -- right into the mouth of
the hydra,'' Patric says. Harrison Ford has already signed on to star in
Carnahan's next film, and a recent issue of Rolling Stone proclaimed Carnahan
a hot director. ''It's like, you're hacking through the jungle with a rusty
butter knife,'' Carnahan says, ''and then, suddenly, the jungle clears
and you see a landing strip with an F-16 on it, waiting for you.''
The story of how a little-known
filmmaker with a little movie became such a big deal over a period of just
a few months has much to do with the magic wand of star power -- in this
case, the wand of Tom Cruise, who saw ''Narc'' last spring and, under the
auspices of his production company, brokered its deal at Paramount. (Tom
Hanks recently provided similarly critical back-channel support as a producer
of the comedy ''My Big Fat Greek Wedding.'') It also has much to do with
the communicable, instinctively herding nature of buzz in Hollywood, especially
when that buzz is harnessed to power. And in that, Carnahan says, ''it
all comes back to the joke.''
Like any decent Cinderella
story, this one begins with its protagonist toiling in obscurity. A burly,
6-foot-2 grocery-store owner's son from rural Michigan, Carnahan had, until
recently, limited expectations for his filmmaking career. He made his first
movie five years ago, borrowing equipment on weekends from the Sacramento
TV station where he worked editing promotional trailers to shoot a quick
and dirty crime story about used-car salesmen called ''Blood Guts Bullets
and Octane.'' The entire thing cost around $7,300. ''I did it as a lark,''
Carnahan says, ''just to do it.'' In 1998, after the film played at the
Sundance Film Festival, Lions Gate Films, an independent film company,
bought it for $150,000 and released it in a small handful of theaters.
Few people ever saw it, but many who did glimpsed signs of a promising
filmmaker: ''What Carnahan made for his money,'' Roger Ebert wrote, ''is
a fabulous calling card.'' Still, in terms of industry buzz, ''Blood Guts
Bullets and Octane'' was, essentially, a mosquito.
Next, Carnahan began
shopping around the script for ''Narc,'' which originated as a short film
he'd made while a student at San Francisco State. He pitched it as a raw
cop drama in the tradition of the 70's films of Sidney Lumet and William
Friedkin. The lack of interest was overwhelming. ''I heard it from all
quarters,'' Carnahan says. '' 'This is an ''N.Y.P.D. Blue'' episode.' 'Nobody
cares about the cop genre anymore.' ''
In time, the script landed
in the hands of Liotta, who had recently moved over to Carnahan's agency,
Endeavor, in hopes of recharging his slumping career. ''I was looking for
a movie that would have some impact,'' Liotta says, ''or at least make
some cash.'' The actor set up a meeting with Carnahan. ''Joe said, 'I want
to do this as a Cassavetes-meets-French Connection'' kind of thing.' You
could tell he'd done his homework. I thought, I want this guy to get a
shot.'' Liotta agreed both to star in the film and to produce it.
For a year, the lights
in the movie's path remained red. Few production companies were eager to
throw millions of dollars at a violent Ray Liotta cop flick, and those
that did express some interest had their own casting ideas. ''I remember
hearing a particular name, I think it was a Baldwin brother: 'If you get
this guy, you'll get three shelves at Blockbuster,' '' Carnahan says. ''I
wanted to put a gun to my head.'' Finally, an independent outfit called
Cutting Edge Entertainment agreed to produce ''Narc,'' and in February
2000 Carnahan began a 28-day shoot in Toronto.
Within two weeks of filming,
the movie's financing began drying up, and Carnahan and his stars were
forced to defer their salaries. ''Every day I got up and didn't know if
we'd be shooting or shutting down,'' Diane Nabatoff, a producer on the
film, recalls. One evening in a bar, Liotta bumped into Michael Douglas
and the producer Arnold Kopelson, who had heard rumors of the movie's problems.
'' 'You've got to walk,' '' Liotta remembers Douglas saying. '' 'Get out
of there.' '' Within a week or so, new investors surfaced, handing over
checks in exchange for producer credits. In the end, there would be 17
producers listed on ''Narc,'' only a handful of whom Carnahan actually
knew.
Last winter, Lions Gate,
which had bought the film's domestic distribution rights for close to $2
million, submitted it to Sundance, where it was accepted into the dramatic
competition. In style and subject, ''Narc'' stood out from the festival
field and drew considerable notice. ''People were surprised how much they
liked it,'' John Cooper, Sundance's director of programming, says. ''You
think: police drama, Ray Liotta, Jason Patric -- whatever. But the audience
felt like they were watching a director who knew what he was doing.'' Nevertheless,
when the awards were handed out, ''Narc'' was passed over. '' 'Reservoir
Dogs' didn't win anything its year either,'' Cooper says. The Sundance
crowd, Patric adds, tends to favor ''movies about lesbian ex-nuns who hand
out pamphlets in the ghetto, shot on digital video.''
Following Sundance, Lions
Gate began to screen the film privately to members of Hollywood's elite
on what is commonly referred to as the Bel-Air circuit. Previewing a film
well before its release for stars and dealmakers is standard practice and
serves a dual purpose: the screener sows seeds of buzz in the industry's
richest fertilizer, and the screenee gets an early look at up-and-coming
talent. ''People want to know who's young and hip for their own careers,''
Liotta says, ''and Joe was the new guy in town.''
One of the first to see
''Narc'' was Dustin Hoffman, another Endeavor client. ''Dustin flipped
out,'' Carnahan says. ''I spent like three and a half hours talking to
him.'' Ron Meyer, the head of Universal Studios, screened the movie at
his house; Warren Beatty was among the guests, and he also called to voice
his enthusiasm. David Geffen asked to see the film. ''Pretty soon,'' Carnahan
says, ''I'm sitting in a room with people a scant few months before I wouldn't
have been able to get within 10 feet of.'' Over lunch, Carnahan says, William
Friedkin told him ''Narc'' was ''the best cop film ever.''
In March, after ''Narc''
had been making the rounds for a month and a half, Cruise's producing partner,
Paula Wagner, called Lions Gate and requested the film. After seeing it,
she phoned Cruise and urged him to watch it. ''I was absolutely blown away,''
Cruise says. ''To see something so fresh -- it was exhilarating, really.
I called Steven Spielberg and said, 'You have to see this film.' And I
called Paula and said, 'I'd like to meet Joe Carnahan.' ''
They set up a meeting,
and Cruise's enthusiasm for the film was obvious. ''He couldn't have gotten
it any more thoroughly,'' Carnahan says. ''He was pointing out particular
shots, elucidating things.'' Carnahan asked Cruise if he could lend his
support, and Cruise agreed.
Cruise and Wagner have
been closely aligned with Paramount since establishing their production
company, Cruise-Wagner Productions, there in 1993. They attached themselves
to ''Narc'' as executive producers and asked the studio to distribute it.
''This was a rather unique situation for us,'' Wagner says, ''to be like
-- what's the right word? -- like godparents, in a way. But if Tom Cruise's
name can help call attention to a film that is so deserving, great.''
''We're trying to be
the angel over the shoulder, really,'' Cruise says. ''What a studio like
Paramount can do is guarantee the theaters, hold them for as long as possible
and spend the kind of money that should be spent.''
Paramount acquisition
executives first scouted ''Narc'' around the time of Sundance, with an
eye toward possibly buying its foreign distribution rights. But as Rob
Friedman, vice chairman of Paramount, says, ''Things definitely heated
up when Tom and Paula were excited about it.'' It also didn't hurt that
Friedkin, who'd been so enamored of the film, is married to the chairwoman
of Paramount, Sherry Lansing. Within two weeks of Cruise's seeing the film,
a deal was in place for Paramount to acquire domestic rights from Lions
Gate for about $3 million. (Technically, the deal is a partnership; Lions
Gate remains involved on a consulting basis and will get a percentage of
the film's grosses. But, as Liotta says, ''It's Paramount's ball and bat
and dollar.'') ''It was just like bam, bam, bam,'' Carnahan says. ''Suddenly
I heard, 'Paramount's buying the film, and Tom's the reason.' ''
One person familiar with
the deal says that Cruise and Paramount's interests in ''Narc'' go beyond
pure love of the film: ''One of the absurdities nobody seems to blink an
eye at is that Cruise and Wagner saw the movie after it was completed and
attached themselves as executive producers, as if they had something to
do with making it. They want to be associated with cool, cutting-edge entertainment,
just to brand themselves. And Paramount is in this mostly for their relationship
with Tom Cruise.''
Cruise insists he's only
helping out as a fan. ''I even said to Joe: 'Look, you don't have to give
us credit. We don't want credit on this movie.' But they wanted us to do
it to try to get some attention for the picture. We literally get nothing
out of this outside of the satisfaction of putting the movie in the best
position it can possibly be in.''
Paramount based its decision
to release ''Narc'' in December on the theory that, while a dark, violent,
marquee-starless genre film may not offer the usual easy publicity hooks
(Ray Liotta is an unlikely cover subject for, say, Vanity Fair), if it
garners enough critics associations' awards and makes enough 10-best lists,
audiences will be curious what all the fuss is about. ''December is a time
when the critical community's antennae are particularly sensitive,'' Friedman
says. ''We think 'Narc' is a big Academy Awards picture that'll be heavily
considered in many categories. That process starts now: building the reputation
of the movie, letting people discover it.'' The ultimate hope, Friedman
says, is that ''Narc'' will be ''the classic case of the little engine
that could.''
Much to Carnahan's amazement,
in a few short months a low-profile project that had once been deemed,
by consensus opinion, to be cinema non grata has been transformed, by consensus
opinion, into a highly anticipated awards film. ''Hollywood is the land
of the nodding heads,'' the director says. ''All the tributaries empty
into the vast sea of perception. Having the muscle that is Tom Cruise and
Paramount behind you changes people's perception, puts the movie in a new
light. It's like having the most popular kid in school throw his arm around
you and say, 'You're my new best friend.' ''
Soon after the Paramount
deal was sealed, Harrison Ford attended a screening of ''Narc'' in New
York. On May 9, Carnahan's birthday, the director received a call from
Ford, raving about the film. Less than a week later, Variety reported that
Carnahan would direct Ford in a crime thriller, ''A Walk Among the Tombstones,''
for Universal. Ford would later be quoted in the press as calling ''Narc''
''the best movie I've ever seen.'' Carnahan is set to begin shooting ''A
Walk Among the Tombstones'' early next year, after which he plans to direct
an adaptation of Mark Bowden's best-selling book ''Killing Pablo.'' ''If
Ray had never come along,'' he says, ''I'd be looking for, like, the Mary-Kate
and Ashley Olsen erotic-thriller vehicle now.''
In Hollywood, fairy tales
are often written in disappearing ink; in the end, Carnahan says, it's
the work, and the hunger for the next gig, that make a career. ''Look,
I'm glad I can get my phone calls returned,'' he says. ''But you know what?
It ain't for lack of trying. While buddies of mine were going to keggers
Friday night, I was staying home writing scripts that I'd print out and
put in my closet. Now those guys I used to know are going, 'Hey, dude,
I've got a screenplay.' ''
|