[OTC Journal] Hello and welcome
to the fourth and the last in a series of four interviews the OTC Journal
has presented every Wednesday through this month of August. Today
we are joined by Geoff Genovese, who is the Chairman and CEO of Envoy Communications,
which trades on the Nasdaq under the symbol ECGI and has a dual listing
on the Toronto Stock Exchange under the symbol ECG. In terms of value,
we believe we have saved the best for last. At the OTC Journal we
have been covering Envoy since July of 1999 during that time on the Canadian
market we have seen the stock as high as $10.20 and the low on the Canadian
market has been $2.10. Currently the stock is trading at a $1.80
in the U.S. market and $2.80 in the Canadian market, so it’s near the bottom
end of its trading range over the last two years. At the OTC Journal
we believe the market will begin to improve in the fourth quarter, and
we also fervently believe now is the time to evaluate your holdings and
plan for the next bull market, look at these companies to figure out which
ones will do well from the next bull market. This series of interviews
is designed to help you understand the four companies we continue to focus
on. As always we remind you that the companies the OTC Journal features
are highly risky, please go to out website at www.otcjournal.com, read
the mission statement on the home page, our article titled “Our Microcaps
for You,” and our section entitled “Rules for Successful Microcap Investing.”
Now before we go on let me read the Safe Harbor Statement. Certain
of the statements contained in this interview are forward-looking statements.
While these statements reflect the corporation’s current beliefs, they
are subject to uncertainties of risk that can cause actual results to differ
materially. These factors include, but are not limited to the demand
for the corporation’s products and services, economic and competitive conditions,
access to borrowed or equity capital on favorable terms, and other risk
details in the corporations SEC filings. So now that we have that
out of the way, let’s get on with the interview. Today we are joined
by Geoff Genovese, who is the President and Chairman of Envoy Communications.
Geoff thanks a lot for joining us today. Before we get started I
would like to mention that at the OTC Journal, we believe that Envoy is
worth at least twice its current price, despite the general decline in
the economy. We believe the company is ridiculously undervalued even
in this current challenging marketing environment. We think everyone
ought to take a hard look at it. It’s been disappointing for us because
in the two and a half years we’ve been covering the company, the company
has continued to grow dramatically in both revenues and earnings yet the
stock is very near the low end of its trading range.
[OTC Journal] So Geoff now
that we’ve got our thoughts out of the way can you give us a brief description
of Envoy’s business model and what Envoy does?
[Geoff Genovese] Envoy is
a communications company in the sense that we provide marketing services
and technology services to a blue chip customer base. The three services
that we operate in are design, which is about 50% of our business, advertising,
which is about 25% of our business, and technology, which is the last 25%
of our business. Now the technology group is split into both infrastructure
and front-end usability web design. So those are the areas that we
operate in. We also operate in Canada, we have about 27% of our revenue
in the Canadian marketplace, 50% in the U.S., and 23% in the U.K.
So we are very diversified from marketing, design, technology and by country.
So it has really rounded out our organization and it’s really helped us
to consistently grow our revenue and our profitability with the exception
of this last quarter.
[OTC Journal] Geoff, I want
to go to the design issue a little bit, you said that 50% of your revenues
come from the design side of your business. Can you give people some
specific examples of the kind of design work you do for large multinational
companies?
[Geoff Genovese] Sure, we
do I guess three really different kinds of, well we do all design whether
it be product design, but its broken down into package design, which is
a large part of our business in the design side, it also is store design
and corporate identity design. So to give you an example, we pretty
much do Wal-Marts package design globally. We also have done the
logo work and identity work for Wal-Mart. We put the star in the
Wal-Mart brand. And we’ve done store design for them as well.
[OTC Journal] So Wal-Mart
is the largest single customer in the design end of it?
[Geoff Genovese] Yeah, we’ve
been working with them for seventeen years now and our design group actually
dealt with and sold to Sam Walton before he passed away.
[OTC Journal] Well let’s move
on to looking at some of the financial history of the company, I want to
go back to this specifically Geoff because we get a lot of questions on
this from our subscribers. In Volume 4, Issue 36 of the OTC Journal,
which we published on April 20th, we predicted the following financial
performance for your company for this fiscal year, which ends at the end
of September. We predicted that you would do about $90 million in
sales, these are Canadian dollars because the company is based in Toronto
so they report in Canadian dollars. $90 million in sales in Canadian
dollars, $16 million in Canadian EBITDA profits, after subtracting the
non cash side of it we figured you would do about $10 million in actual
cash profits and that would translate because we like to look at the stock
in the U.S. market because the vast majority of our members trade in the
U.S. market, that would translate to roughly $6 million in cash profits
in U.S. dollars or about $0.32 a share in real cash profits. So being
as we are six weeks away from the end of the fiscal year, what’s your feeling
as to whether or not you could actually achieve this result? Do you
feel you’re on track or are we going to fall a little behind or what’s
your feeling on it Geoff?
[Geoff Genovese] Well, why
don’t I run through the numbers as you listed them? Well the $90
million dollars in Canadian sales or revenue, as we call it, it is clear
that we will not achieve this, we will achieve revenue in the low $80’s,
but that’s up significantly, 50% to 60% over our previous year. We
felt that we had a very aggressive growth target for the year and we are
outperforming our peer group, but we are personally disappointed we didn’t
hit the $90 million. It’s a tough business climate and also we’ve
had some timing issues with some of our big projects with some of our customers.
[OTC Journal] So as I remember
wasn’t it roughly $57 million in fiscal 2000?
[Geoff Genovese] That’s right.
We actually did $58.6 million and we’ll end up this year somewhere in the
low $80’s.
[OTC Journal] Well still that’s
a substantial increase over $58 million in 2000.
[Geoff Genovese] Now in terms
of EBITDA, last year we finished the year with about $10.2 million in EBITDA
profits and this year we believe that we will beat that number, but it
will probably end up in terms of EBITDA per share between $0.51 and $0.53
in EBITDA. So our profitability and our margin are lower than we
obviously expected it to be. And that’s largely due to a few things,
one our technology group is not performing as profitable as we had hoped
for the year and that’s a big part of it. And secondly I mentioned
timing before, we had a lot of customers, some of our biggest customers,
postpone some of their big projects. The good news is that during
that last part of our third quarter the big projects that we anticipated
were finally confirmed, we got our PO’s for them, and are now working diligently
to get that revenue in for this fiscal, we won’t get it all in and we won’t
get all the profits that we wanted in, so it will result in us missing
our target.
[OTC Journal] So it would
be fair to say you’ve had a hiccup in terms of the business flow that you
anticipated, but it’s already righting itself, so to speak?
It is not back to what we had hoped
to, but we are still outperforming our peer group on an average quite significantly.
Most of our peer group is only receiving a 2% to 6% increase in profitability
year after year. Most of them are down and will end up the year up.
[OTC Journal] So can you make
any kind of prognostication or give us some kind of idea of where you might
be at the end of the year in terms of EBITDA?
[Geoff Genovese] Yeah, I think
I just did Larry, I said somewhere between $0.51 and $0.53.
[OTC Journal] $0.53 a share?
[Geoff Genovese] Yes.
Now it’s been a difficult environment, but we have seen some signs of it
improving forth. There was a recent article, I think out in the Globe,
which I think is a pickup from the Wall Street Journal, that two of the
prominent analysts, Lauren Fine from Merrill Lynch and Robert Kohne from
Universal McKahn, all are predicting that the business in 2002 is going
to rebound and they are looking for a better year than this year.
[OTC Journal] So moving forward
to evaluation of your company, if we are looking at as a function of sales,
which is the easy way to look at it, you are looking at your market capitalization,
in other words the stock market is saying your company is worth about $40
million U.S., yet your on track to do $50 million in revenues and I’m sure
there is some other comparatives. How does your value relative to
your financial performance compare to other companies in your peer group
that are publicly traded?
[Geoff Genovese] Let’s just
take Omnicom, because that was just written up in the Wall Street Journal
and they are saying it is going to outperform one of the indexes.
But Omnicom for example right now is trading at 24 times cash flow or 29
times their 2001 estimate. And if you looked at and compared apples
to apples, our cash, EPS, or our net earnings before goodwill, because
as you know Larry, come this following fiscal year, in Canada and the U.S.
you will not be writing off goodwill anymore. And we’ve been a bit
handicapped in Canada because we have had to write off our goodwill.
So if you took our numbers, Omnicom is trading at about 29 times and I
believe we are trading at about 12 times. So well below 50% a company
like Omnicom.
[OTC Journal] So would it
be a fair statement to say, Geoff, that even though as the CEO of the company
it is not your position to toggle a price on the stock that it should be
trading at if it got the same multiple as Omnicom. It would be fair
to say that compared to your peer group, Envoy is ridiculously undervalued?
[Geoff Genovese] Yeah, there
is no question. Another way to look at it is we are 5 times our EBITDA
number. Omnicom is trading on next years EBITDA numbers of about
12 times.
[OTC Journal] Omnicom is not
experiencing growth that takes them from a percentage growth that takes
them from $58 million to $80 million on an annual basis, right?
[Geoff Genovese] That is correct.
[OTC Journal] So you are growing
at a much faster rate with a much lower multiple to your profits.
[Geoff Genovese] That’s right.
So we are outperforming them in terms of growth and our stock is lagging
way behind. That is partly because we have no coverage in the U.S.
marketplace.
[OTC Journal] Yeah we are
going to talk about that a little bit later. Let’s plow through the
number stuff before we get onto what you have planned in the future.
I just wanted to go over the third quarter numbers real quickly mostly
because you announced you actually had a paper loss for the June quarter
after 21 consecutive quarters of both growth and sales and earnings.
So could you talk to our members a little bit about how you actually logged
a non cash loss even though your revenue growth was up 60% the same quarter
the previous year?
[Geoff Genovese] And you’re
asking about just the quarter?
[OTC Journal] Yes, just your
fiscal third quarter.
[Geoff Genovese] Because for
our 9 month we made about $9.2 million before that unusual item.
The unusual item or the charge that we took in the third quarter was approximately
$2.1 million, which was the cost that we incurred on the Legas Delaney
acquisition that we did not complete.
[OTC Journal] So the reason
that you reported a loss was because you wrote down $2.1 million that was
associated with a one-time event that didn’t come around for you?
[Geoff Genovese] That’s correct.
[OTC Journal] So it’s not
part of your normal day-to-day operation?
[Geoff Genovese] That’s correct.
[OTC Journal] Geoff, one more
quick question about that. If you did not have the $2.1 million loss,
how would the numbers have looked for that quarter? Do you have that
information handy?
[Geoff Genovese] Well I think
we reported that in our press release. We did earnings per share
before goodwill or cash EPS, we did $0.17 before that charge and about
$9.2 million of EBITDA profit before that one time charge.
[OTC Journal] So let’s move
on to a little bit of a discussion about the stock itself. Now a
year ago I know there was institutional participation in the stock.
Can you describe what happened to your institutional participation over
the past year, where are we today as opposed to a year ago?
[Geoff Genovese] Well, I don’t
know of a fund that holds it any longer. As you know we did a couple
financings last year, to mostly institutions. And pretty well all
of those institutions have traded out of us, partly because of our own
success in our last calendar year. Because we have a fair amount
of liquidity for a small cap stock, and its only small cap money managers
that would be buying us, they received a lot of redemptions and they looked
at companies that they could actually trade. Because a lot of their
investment, they couldn’t sell their stock. So we are a bit of a
victim of our own success, in terms that we trade some pretty good volumes
for a small cap company. So a lot of the institutions traded out
of us because they had cash redemptions.
[OTC Journal] So you feel
like the stock had a fairly decent institutional participation, for the
most part from Canadian institutions, a year ago, now you have none and
you feel it’s because money managers have been forced to sell because of
redemptions?
[Geoff Genovese] Well yes,
or their mandates have changed. We had one money manager in the Canadian
marketplace where he left the company and the new guy comes on and cleans
out his portfolio. So that happens as well, but what we are finding
is there really isn’t a lot of long-term money. There usually in
for six months or a year, which is a real disappointment to us because
we had hoped that they would be three to five year money. But I think
the good news is Larry, at least as far as I’m concerned, is right now
there isn’t any institutions of any consequence that hold any positions
in our stock and I think that our stock has really held its own with the
retail investors, its in these large institutional blocks that come up
for sale that really put the downward pressure on our stock.
[OTC Journal] So the reason
you are saying that is good news is because institutions can no longer
hurt the stock and new institutions that come in at this point can only
help it.
[Geoff Genovese] Absolutely.
So I think that because the stock market is just supply and demand, I think
that those large blocks that create that oversupply have traded out of
our stock. So consequentially I hope that there will be more demand
than supply and our stock will start to firm up.
[OTC Journal] Geoff, at the
OTC Journal we have always viewed it as a little bit of a weakness, we
have always known that you had Canadian institutional supporting your stock,
but you basically never had any U.S. support in your stock, your based
in Toronto, you trade on the Toronto Stock Exchange, you’re a Canadian
company, yet more than 50% of your business is done in the U.S.
[Geoff Genovese] Yes and I
would think that right now in terms of share ownership or from a shareholder
base, I would say that at least 50% if not 60% U.S. based.
[OTC Journal] Well can you
talk to us a little bit about any plans you have in store for exposing
your company to a U.S. institutional audience.
[Geoff Genovese] Well you
know about two months ago we hired a firm called MWW out of New York, which
is a fairly large U.S. or New York based media relations or investor relations
firm. So what we’ve been doing over the last 60 to 90 days with them
is developing our communications strategy and our presentation. Because
what we plan to do mid to late September, is we are planning to do a road
show in the U.S. to institutions and retail brokers. So we hope to
crank up our presence in the United States.
[OTC Journal] So you are planning
an institutional road show for mid to late September.
[Geoff Genovese] Not only
an institutional road show, but to retail brokers as well through MWW.
[OTC Journal] Geoff can you
talk to us about the stock buy back program that you announced on July
24th, where are you with that and how is that going to progress?
[Geoff Genovese] Well as you
know we did announce it and in our first month of trading I think we purchased
about 330,000 or 340,000 shares of Envoy. We think it is a tremendous
value here and we are going to continue to purchase our stock at this level.
[OTC Journal] So you were
able to purchase about 350,000 shares, is there a limit as to how many
shares you are going to buy back?
[Geoff Genovese] Yes, we can
buy back roughly 2 million shares in a given year.
[OTC Journal] And do you intend
to buy them all back?
[Geoff Genovese]As I said
we think it’s a tremendous value here and our focus is to continue to do
strategic acquisitions, but we think the best use of our proceeds right
now is to buy our own stock because its so cheap.
[OTC Journal] Can you talk
a little bit about where the cash comes from to buy your shares back?
[Geoff Genovese] Well as you
know Envoy has a strong balance sheet. We have some where in the
neighborhood of about $12 million of cash on our balance sheet and we have
very little debt as you know. We also just finished a meeting today
approving on a director’s level our $40 million acquisition line.
So we hope to have that in place by the end of the week and its obviously
been all approved and the bank is just doing their final documentation.
So this line of credit will allow us to continue our buy back and to do
strategic acquisitions.
[OTC Journal] So what your
saying is you’ve had a $40 million line of credit approved by banks and
you intend to use that as a source of capital for both buy backs and acquisitions?
[Geoff Genovese] Yes, absolutely.
[OTC Journal] Now I’m going
to throw some questions at you that were e-mailed to us directly by some
of our members. Geoff, people want to know if you, in light of the
fact the stock has traded so poorly over the last 6 to 9 months, would
you ever consider providing shareholders with a dividend as a way of creating
a return on their investment as opposed to reinvesting all the money in
the company?
[Geoff Genovese]No, no we
wouldn’t. We are, and we’ve said this since the onset, a growth company.
We feel that we can continue to grow the company, our 60% growth is pretty
good, we are very unhappy with our share price and I’m sure the shareholders
are as well, but we think that if we keep taking care of the business the
share price will come back and that we do the right things in terms of
the road show.
[OTC Journal] Here’s another
question, you have quite an impressive list of Canadian customers with
large multinational names. One of our members wants to know if you
can leverage that Canadian customer base into customers in the U.S., specifically
they mentioned Sprint and Lexus?
[Geoff Genovese] Well I cant
really talk specifics in terms of leveraging our customers, but certainly
that is one of our goals and we are leveraging both our U.S. customer base,
because 50% of our business is in the U.S., into the Canadian marketplace
and we have been very successful with Wal-Mart, we’re doing their work
now really globally. So we’ve had some very good successes at leveraging
our customer base.
[OTC Journal] Now here’s an
interesting question for you, I would think that with a $40 million market
cap and the kinds of numbers you’ve been able to generate you would be
an attractive acquisition candidate. In other words instead of you
acquiring smaller companies, someone acquiring you. Has anybody expressed
any interest in acquiring Envoy?
[Geoff Genovese] Well I can’t
really comment on that, but there is a lot of value in our share price
right now, we are trading at a very low EBITDA multiple. Much lower
than some of the companies that we have purchased in the past. So
we are certainly attractive at this price.
[OTC Journal] Another question
relates to your corporate website, I haven’t looked at it personally in
a little while, but our members are reporting that it is not functioning
very well. Are you guys working on that?
[Geoff Genovese] I think what
they could be referring to Larry, is that we had up at the top right hand
corner of the site, the latest stock price and that was not functioning
at one point. I think that has been corrected and we are in the process
of redesigning the entire site.
[OTC Journal] Just let me
mention, as long as we came to that issue that if your looking for a quote
on the stock the scrolling ticker on your OTC Journal has it live all the
time for people that need it. Okay Geoff, let’s wrap this up.
I think that it would be appropriate for you to make a comment for us on
where you see Envoy’s future. Just in general terms, what do you
see happening in fiscal 2002 and then can you talk to us a little about
where you hope to take the company in terms of where you hope to take the
stock in the next five years?
[Geoff Genovese] Well I really
can’t project out that kind of distance, but I really feel there is a tremendous
amount of potential at Envoy. If you take a look at our design group
for example, it is a world leader in design, it is probably the leader
in retail design and the design business really is an area of business
that has not been consolidated to the degree that any of the other, the
technology or the advertising sectors have. So there is a tremendous
opportunity for us to grow that business. And the company that I
am referring to is WATT, and we bought the WATT Group about two and a half
years ago doing about $10 million in revenue or sales and this year we
will do about $45 million. So we’ve had a tremendous amount of growth
and I think we can continue that kind of growth. I think that it
is a great business; it is a business that really hasn’t been effected
by the recession or the slow economy if you don’t want to use the “R-word.”
So I think there is a tremendous amount of potential for us to keep growing
that business. We’ve got a very strong marketing and advertising
group and there’s a lot of potential there still. We’ve launched
John Street, which I think is really exciting and a real talented group
and they are going to go out and win business and I think our organic growth
rate is really going to pick up, it was 14% for the year, 60% overall growth,
but 14% came from organic growth and I think that we can really turn that
number up.
[OTC Journal] I think that
would be a good point to wrap it up, the 14% organic growth has to be way
ahead of the industry average. So obviously you guys are doing some
things right and lets hope it eventually gets reflected in the price of
the stock. Ladies and gentlemen this concludes our four part series
of audio interviews for August. We hope this spiced up your August
a little bit. We saved Envoy for last because we feel in terms of
value Envoy is by far the most undervalued company that we represent currently.
People who invest at these levels, we believe are going to see excellent
returns over the next six months or so. As Geoff told you institutions
have been forced to sell shares maybe against their will, maybe for redemptions,
maybe because fund managers have changed due to market conditions and it’s
just an opportunity. So thanks again for joining us, have a great
day, and we’ll be back.
|